The rise and fall of Scotland’s referees

FROM death threats and resignations to Euro 2012 and the Champions League knockout stages, in the space of three years. Standards of refereeing in Scotland are seemingly on the up but have they really improved?

The state of the Scottish game, often the subject of criticism and interrogation, reached its lowest ebb in 2010.

Accusations of bias were widespread, experienced officials were forced out, referees were being manhandled, linesmen grabbed by the throat while the turmoil resulted in a national strike affecting several fixtures across the country.

Colleagues from Israel, Luxembourg and Malta were recruited to overcome the unprecedented walk-out, just a month after ref Willie Collum raised safety fears after handling an ill-tempered Old Firm clash.

As the media frenzy reached breaking point, Dougie McDonald gave his notice having lied to a supervisor in that bizarre episode which quickly became a series of controversies.

charlie richmondCharlie Richmond claimed favouritism towards certain match officials was rife within the authorities and the selection process was often influenced.

“Apparently I’m not a team player. My interpretation is it means I don’t suck up to the right people,” he declared at the time.

Even SFA talks for an increase in match fees hit a stumbling block.

Fast forward 28 months – and the picture has transformed dramatically, largely for the better it has to be said.

Since then, Referee Development Officer John Fleming promised an overhaul in bringing parties together and imposing tougher sanctions.

The men in the middle have had their fees bumped up £40 per game too, so all is well.OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA

The Respect campaign has enhanced the relationship between players, managers and match officials which threatened to spiral out of control.

After January’s promotion of Paul Robertson, the country now has seven Uefa-listed refs compared to just four, three years ago.

The introduction of an annual New Year warm-weather training camp in Spain has helped boost morale, fitness and communication between officials.

Despite axing the mandatory retirement age, the SFA have ushered the 40-somethings out of the door and fast-tracked promising younger talent.

John Beaton, Bobby Madden and Kevin Clancy have progressed to the highest level while at the age of 32, Steven McLean stepped out at Celtic Park recently to officiate the League Cup Final.

Craig Thomson beat off competition from some of the best whistlers on the continent to become one of 12 referees at Euro 2012.

He was joined in the last 16 of Europe’s premier competition last term by the highly-rated Collum, who insisted during the transitional period that Scottish refereeing is “thriving”.

celtic vs rangers old firm derbyAlthough card statistics and major incidents decreased in 2013, the absence of Celtic’s titanic rivalry with Rangers was felt while next season’s top-flight will be without the explosive Edinburgh derby.

The rescinded dismissals of Victor Wanyama, Johnny Russell, Jamie Hamill and Nadir Ciftci, amongst others, prove that referees’ integrity continues to be questioned.

Fans may remain sceptical towards officiating north of the border but all the signposts are pointing down the road of recovery and a future filled with optimism.


Charlie Richmond Image by Graeme Bird via Creative Commons/License

Dons vs Gers Image by @notnixon via Creative Commons/License

Rangers Attack Image by FLC via Creative Commons/License

One thought on “The rise and fall of Scotland’s referees”

  1. Improvements have definitely been made, and I think the decision to give many younger referees a chance was a good one. Maybe the real results will be shown when we next see one officiate at the world cup!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.